Electron Microscope Captures Lithium Atom Images

BERKELEY, Calif., July 17 -- For the first time, researchers have used a transmission electron microscope -- the One-Angstrom Microscope (OAM) at the Department of Energy's National Center for Electron Microscopy (NCEM) at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory -- to image lithium atoms. Only atoms of hydrogen and helium are smaller and lighter than lithium, which under ordinary conditions is not a gas but a soft, white metal.

Yang Shao-Horn of the mechanical engineering department at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and Michael O'Keefe of Berkeley Lab's Materials Sciences Division used the OAM to simultaneously resolve columns of lithium, cobalt and oxygen atoms in the compound lithium cobalt oxide (LiCoO2). LiCoO2 is commonly used in the positive electrodes of lithium rechargeable batteries; their operation is based on reversible insertion and removal of lithium ions to and from their positive and negative electrodes. Widely used in laptop computers, digital cameras and many other devices, lithium ion batteries store more energy for their weight, operate at a higher voltage and hold a charge much longer than other rechargeable batteries.

IONIC VISION: The first experimental image of lithium atoms from a transmission electron microscope: The image shows the arrangement of lithium ions among cobalt and oxygen atoms in the compound lithium cobalt oxide. (Photo courtesy of Berkely Labs)

To improve their performance will require understanding how the atoms in the electrode materials -- and the vacancies left by moving ions -- are arranged in 3-D on the atomic scale. The structure of LiCoO2 is known theoretically and has been confirmed with techniques like x-ray diffraction and neutron powder diffraction: Layers of lithium atoms lie between slabs of cobalt and oxygen, which are arranged in octahedrons. But lithium ions have never been seen by these techniques, nor have they been seen in previous attempts to image LiCoO2 with electron microscopy.

So when Shao-Horn, who had been investigating lithium ion batteries with colleagues at the University of Bordeaux I, approached microscopist O'Keefe in the summer of 2001 to ask whether it would be possible to image lithium ions in the material with a high-resolution transmission electron microscope, his first answer was, "I don't think so."

How Transmission Electron Microscopy Works

A transmission electron microscope (TEM) sends a beam of electrons through a thin sample of material; as the beam scatters from the electrical field of the atomic nuclei and their surrounding clouds of electrons, their unique arrangement affects the phase of the beam and, to some extent, its amplitude. When the altered beam exits the surface of a precisely oriented sample, it can be focused by an electromagnetic lens to project an image of the sample's columns of atoms.

Because atoms with small dimensions and very little mass barely affect the electron beam, they are difficult to resolve -- a problem that worsens if there are heavier atoms nearby. Heavy cobalt, with atomic number 27 and atomic mass approaching 60, is relatively easy to image, but light oxygen, with atomic number 8 and atomic mass about 16, scatters electrons weakly. Lithium is even smaller -- its atomic number is only 3, its atomic mass only 7.

A TEM's ability to image these wispy particles depends on many factors, including the microscope beam's energy, energy spread and steadiness and the distortion, or aberration, of the lens. All these combine to determine the smallest distance a microscope can distinguish between two adjacent objects, its native resolution. NCEM's One-Angstrom Microscope is a medium-energy TEM with a native resolution of 1.6 angstroms (an angstrom, symbolized A, is a ten-billionth of a meter), good enough to resolve cobalt atoms directly.

For the highest possible resolution, it is necessary to go beyond native resolution to a microscope's information limit -- the maximum amount of information about the sample that can be extracted from the scattered electron wave, even those portions of it that may be out of phase. One method of achieving this, called focal-series reconstruction, uses a computer to combine successive images, each made at a slightly different focus. In this way, the One-Angstrom Microscope has achieved a resolution as high as 0.78 angstrom.

But there's a catch. Because the separate images in the series are focused differently, in-phase images of atoms in one image will be out of phase in another. How is the computer to know whether bright spots, dim spots or no spots at all belong at particular locations in the composite image? How does the thickness of the sample affect the outcome?

The Right Number of Blobs
To answer these questions, researchers use two kinds of computer programs. With the first, they can create a high-resolution simulation of what the microscope ought to see -- "the right number of blobs for the right number of atoms," as O'Keefe puts it.

The simulation program starts with a model of the material's crystal structure, then dials in atomic specifications, the thickness and orientation of the sample, such parameters as the energy of the microscope's electron beam, lens aberrations, beam misalignments and other characteristics of both the sample and the instrument. Out comes a series of simulated images.

When O'Keefe -- who wrote the first such image simulation program in the late 1970s -- applied a recent version to the theoretical structure of LiCoO2, the simulation providedessential information such as what resolution the microscope had to achieve to see anything at all, and at what resolution all the different kinds of atoms should be sharpest. His initial skepticism about whether lithium atoms could be imaged began to wane. the simulation showed that in a sample of the right thickness, lithium ions should become visible at 1 A. And at 0.8 A, all three kinds of atoms should be clearly visible -- a resolution that was, indeed, just possible to reach with the One-Angstrom Microscope.

O'Keefe says, "The simulation showed that the columns of oxygen atoms should look bright and sharp-edged, the cobalts should be fuzzy and the lithium should be small, weak and look a little stretched."

BLOB ANALYSIS: A simulation program showed how the atoms in lithium cobalt oxide ought to appear. The microscope imaged columns of the component atoms, seen end-on, in a small portion of the sample. (Photo courtesy of Berkely Labs)

In 2002, working with NCEM's Chris Nelson to master the operation of the OAM, Shao-Horn obtained many series of 20 differently focused images of individual crystals from a LiCoO2 powder sample. The sample was prepared and well characterized by conventional X-ray diffraction, in collaboration with her colleagues Laurence Croguennec and Claude Delmas, of the Institute de Chimie de la Matiere Condensee de Bordeaux-CNRS and the Ecole National Superieure de Chimie et Physique de Bordeaux at the University of Bordeaux I.

With a second computer program and their measurements of the microscope parameters, researchers take the experimental images and work backward to produce a representation of the electron wave leaving the exit surface of the specimen. After confirming the focal value for each image in the series, Shao-Horn and her colleagues used the reconstruction program to produce an image from a small area of a thin edge of a LiCoO2 crystal that matched the one predicted by the simulation program.

"Because material from which some lithium ions are removed is somewhat unstable under the electron beam, experimental imaging of the lithium ions and vacancies proved difficult in this study," says Shao-Horn. "Nevertheless, the atomic resolution of lithium atoms is a novel and significant achievement, with implications for better understanding not only of lithium ion battery materials but of many other electroceramic materials as well."

Says O'Keefe, "We have shown that the range of the OAM, and mid-voltage microscopes like it, can be extended all the way from heavy atoms down through oxygen, nitrogen, and carbon to the lightest metal -- in fact, except for helium and hydrogen, the lightest atoms of all."

"Atomic resolution of lithium ions in LiCoO2," by Yang Shao-Horn, Laurence Croguennec, Claude Delmas, E. Chris Nelson, and Michael O'Keefe, appears in the July 2003 issue of Nature Materials.

For more information, visit: www.lbl.gov